Three small treatments. Nine pieces to judge on their own.
Watch the actual code/SVG drafts beside their source footage. Inspect the timing, read the remaining gaps and download the implementation.
These are new comparison drafts of previously studied footage—not three new films or three completed recipes.
3Playable draft comparisons
9Independently scoped pieces
6Static blind verdicts recorded
0Blind wins / zero completed
Last recorded update: . This page does not imply background worker activity.
01 / Actual rendered output
A source on each side of the question.
144 native frames / 4.805 seconds per side. Every excerpt is silent. The labels below are for reference; this public page is not a blind judging room. Timing conformance does not establish visual approval.
Title reveal and reading hold
Source 0.000–2.636 s · 79 native frames · 2.636 s · silent
Choreography: Blank native frame → whole-word groups on the first line → smaller text groups on the second line → reading hold. The following demo cut is outside this excerpt.
Official source excerptCode/SVG draft · not approved
State timing is implemented; moving-source quality and continuity remain unreviewed. The opening begins with one blank native frame. Frame controls buffer these brief, silent clips locally for seeking. Players start together but are not hardware-synchronized; pause and step for aligned frame inspection.
Choreography: Caret hidden → one 34 ms visible frame → hint and plus-color reset together → caret returns. This action-only crop excludes the rest of the interface.
Official source excerptCode/SVG draft · not approved
State timing is implemented; moving-source quality and continuity remain unreviewed. One white bottom row is added to both 125 px crops for even-height H.264 delivery. Frame controls buffer these brief, silent clips locally for seeking. Players start together but are not hardware-synchronized; pause and step for aligned frame inspection.
Choreography: Gray label → a light band travels across the glyphs → brightness falls → gray hold. Band width, trajectory and fade are provisional authoring estimates.
Official source excerptCode/SVG draft · not approved
The light curve is an authoring estimate, not a recovered source shader or approved motion match. One white bottom row is added to both 125 px crops for even-height H.264 delivery. Frame controls buffer these brief, silent clips locally for seeking. Players start together but are not hardware-synchronized; pause and step for aligned frame inspection.
Three static pieces have bound render comparisons. Six timing pieces are implemented in the integrated drafts, but their independent moving-output reviews remain pending.
9 of 9 pieces
No pieces match. Reset the filters to see all nine.
Chunked title → reading hold
0.000–2.636 s · native frames [0,79)
T1-S / Static appearance
Title typography and placement
Two fixed-origin text lines with matching content, contour, spacing, contrast and full-frame composition.
Preserve the completed title through frame 78. Adjacent cut context is retained, but actual continuity into the next shot requires a separate integrated comparison.
Round one preferred the source: the draft crowded the “Th” pair. The spacing repair was rendered and a fresh second critic returned a tie.
Latest result: tie / not accepted
Composer shell
Both static rounds tied. The draft’s darker hint text is a disclosed readability choice, not a recovered source color or an approved improvement.
Latest result: tie / not accepted
Thinking label
Both static rounds tied. A darker resting gray is a disclosed adaptation. The moving light-band curve remains provisional and unjudged.
Latest result: tie / not accepted
Fresh critics inspected anonymous actual still outputs before the identity mappings were revealed. This is declared provenance blinding, not authenticated filesystem isolation. Static judgments cannot pass temporal pieces. A loss or tie goes back to its builder; rerolling unchanged work until someone agrees is not acceptance.
04 / Implementation and boundaries
Code and SVG. Not flattened footage.
React/Remotion components draw the title, composer and light band with SVG. The permitted Geist font is included with its license. Source movies and screenshots are reference evidence, not editable input assets.
The source files match the revisions used in these renders. The timing functions passed 400 tests; native export metadata records each frame’s duration.
What it does not prove
It is not a clean-install-verified standalone toolkit, an original-content reuse certificate or a fidelity-approved recipe. The package does not include a portable native-clock encoder. Ordinary constant-rate export will not reproduce the exact 33/34 ms source clock.
For the broader library and its own review status, use the agent motion guide. Final all-hands production remains a separate approval.
Official source / research only
Interrupting and Adding Details in GPT-5.4 Thinking
The hash-checked local master is 1920 × 1080, 771 native frames, nominal 30000/1001 fps. The full movie stays private. Only the three brief silent research excerpts are included here. No new listening review or full-source moving review has occurred.