# Publication review record

The current packaging disposition is R02 below. The earlier R01 audit follows
unchanged as history, including its then-open findings. R02 closes those two
structural findings only; all visual gaps and zero quality credits remain.

# Batch03 — REPORT-R02: two packaging issues closed

Checked **2026-09-14T00:04:40.225241+00:00**. Append-only follow-up to REPORT-R01; original source and label freezes and all R01 artifacts remain unchanged.

## Decision

**P03-01 and P03-02 are closed for the supplied packet. No structural blocker remains from these two findings.** This closure gives no additional motion, source-fidelity, source-blind, Resolve, or whole-film credit.

- **P03-01 — review wiring:** `batch-03.json` carries the sanitized source/report references, all five gaps, **874 source frames**, **5 Atlas context frames**, and **1,738 candidate frames**. The actual packet includes the source/report documents; its page shows all five gaps and its state preserves the counts and zero quality/moving/blind/Resolve credits.
- **P03-02 — missing installation manifests:** the actual Prompt and Hard Cut ZIPs now contain `overlay-manifest.json`. Both manifests match the delivered core and active archive hashes, core-then-active installation order, member sets, runtime hashes and sizes.

## Exact artifact checked

- Publication manifest SHA-256: `2a991f288535c05b123023a167e16434574207821914b96c67e32907d0c0c00e`.
- Parent delivered-kit check report SHA-256: `bdd4f36c9ddee4d750c78cff32ce54a8ae1970eb50e69949c096d2f7e8853319`; parent test time **2026-09-13T23:55:24.278719+00:00**.
- R01 preservation seal SHA-256: `9e35ca9cefd4d43f807b575df9d11bf361823de1c4d7f6470438e6906b98a589`.
- **76 manifest-listed files** verified for hash and byte count; no unlisted files beyond the manifest. All five ZIP integrity checks passed. Exact per-ZIP, guide, CSV and active archive hashes are in `REPORT-R02.json`.

The five delivered ZIPs include their README, start instructions, guide, own handoff script, controls, core archive, active archive, bindings, render verification and critic record. Delivered guide/README/handoff bytes match the previously audited inputs. Selected recipe and SVG bytes match the exact rendered project. Active archives contain only the selected recipe and used SVGs; both archive layers use `project/` paths. License notices in the core are not a dependency installation.

All **162,636 delivered CSV rows** match the previously audited guide CSV under parsing. The parent's report records unpacking each actual ZIP, executing **its own** handoff and regenerating a byte-identical CSV. I verified that report against the actual ZIP, guide and CSV hashes; **I did not repeat those unpacked executions**. The ten export hashes and native frame counts remain bound to the earlier actual label review. Neither CSV agreement nor packaging agreement establishes Fusion pixel equivalence or motion quality.

## Atlas and review accounting

The delivered Atlas source player is the already-reviewed **110-frame** re-encode, SHA-256 `871dce13569a50ce58912aa62a7f88d6bc7fca203af2f369dee090a7032da9b3`. Public provenance records original local **[5,115)** to declared film **[2695,2805)**, with the original **115-frame** file and its five lead-context frames preserved. I rechecked the original file hash and the delivered player's recorded native clock/count. No lossless trim, pixel identity or freshly recovered master clock is claimed.

Accounting is unchanged: **874 unique source frames**, including five Atlas lead-context frames; **1,738 candidate frames + 869 repeated reference frames** in the label pass. This follow-up adds no frame inspection. The original assessment is consecutive **static inspection**, not moving perception; the references could be recognized.

## Remaining visual gaps — unchanged

| Treatment | Largest remaining gap |
| --- | --- |
| apps-output-wall | Repeated card templates flatten heterogeneous foreground handoffs and page-specific activity. |
| atlas-layered-icon-build | A preformed four-lobed badge replaces development of the shaded overlapping rosette. |
| prompt-device-context | Dark character steps replace the source's pale-to-dark phrase reveal. |
| split-result-pane-allocation | Continuous card narrowing replaces delayed content-responsive conversation reflow. |
| hard-cut-crop | A much smaller post-cut rise weakens the settle overlapping focus and typing. |

All five remain changes-required for source fidelity. No new moving-blind win, completed source-quality example, native Resolve validation or whole-film acceptance is awarded.

## Final packaging gate

The supplied packet embeds the earlier R01 text, SHA-256 `90cee4e880554f23665f5da94036103ee3803bec0d3bf00a621d1ad63190c6d0`, rather than the later sealed R01 wording. That version is explicitly pinned here; no historical artifact has been rewritten.

**The parent must bind R02 into the final packet, rebuild it, and rerun all five actual delivered-ZIP handoff and byte-identical-CSV checks.** The checks reported here apply only to the manifest hash above and do not pre-pass that future packet. No encode, install, dependency copy, deployment or production replacement occurred in this follow-up.

---

# Earlier full audit: R01, preserved

# Batch03 — unblinded guide and portability audit R01

Audit cutoff: **2026-09-13T23:47:58Z**; parent packaging corrections rechecked **2026-09-13T23:55:47Z**. The label verdict was sealed at **2026-09-13T23:32:57+00:00**, before the role key or builder guides were opened. Source and label freezes remain unchanged. This report is bounded to the five batch03 treatments and their actual runtime inputs and exports.

## Publication blockers

Two packaging blockers were found and sent to the parent. **Both are resolved in the parent-owned batch manifest at the final recheck.** No open packaging blocker remains in this bounded input/wiring audit; the final delivered-archive test is still pending. Neither correction changes a rendered candidate.

1. **Resolved: missing review wiring — all five.** The audited manifest lacked `review`, which `build_preview.py:148`, line 281, and lines 304–309 require. The parent now binds the sanitized source/report filenames, all five gaps, `sourceFrames: 874`, `extraContextFrames: 5`, and `candidateFrames: 1738`. These match the handoff fields below. No private freeze is selected for publication.
2. **Resolved: missing required overlay manifest — Prompt and Hard Cut.** Their READMEs read `overlay-manifest.json` and check its archive checksum before extraction. The audited entries omitted it, and `build_preview.py:187` only includes declared extra files. The parent now supplies `extraFiles: ["overlay-manifest.json"]` for both. Existing archive hashes match the active-archive bytes computed with the actual publication function. This computed the active archive in memory only, not the final public ZIP.

The parent must still build and unpack the **final public ZIPs**, then rerun their own delivered handoff and CSV checks. **That final-package test has not been done by this critic.** The successful checks below use the exact rendered runtime and current guide files, not an assertion about a future archive.

## Unblinded frozen verdict

| Treatment | Default | Adaptation | Reference | Frozen preference | Default/adaptation result |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| apps-output-wall | A | C | B | B | Tie |
| atlas-layered-icon-build | A | B | C | C | Tie |
| prompt-device-context | B | C | A | A | Tie |
| split-result-pane-allocation | B | C | A | A | Tie |
| hard-cut-crop | A | B | C | C | Tie |

Each preferred label resolves to the recognizable reference. **This is not a source-blind win or source-quality certification.** The tie means this bounded static pass did not establish a defensible material motion advantage between the two implementations. Different palettes, names, or demo subjects alone do not create a winner.

Coverage remains **874 original source-only frames**, including five Atlas lead-context frames. The label pass inspected **1,738 candidate frames + 869 repeated reference frames = 2,607 labeled frames**. It did not add 869 new unique source frames. Every native consecutive frame, including quiet intervals, was covered in static sheets. The label pass normalized spatially to 960×540 before 320×180 overview tiles; fifteen full normalized contexts and five detail sheets supplemented those overviews. No moving perception, native Resolve, or whole-film credit is granted.

## One largest remaining gap per treatment

### apps-output-wall

**Repeated schematic cards flatten the heterogeneous foreground handoffs and page-specific activity.** At local f164 the reference has the blue orbital page overlapping the lime event page among distinct schedules, portraits, charts, and maps; the implementations emphasize recurring bar/list/play-card families. Both implementations retain real layer translation, scaling, and occlusion, plus the pullback, f248 hard replacement, and staggered brackets. They are not static posters. The main remaining difference is the variety and internal activity of the wall across f30–223, not absence of the macro sequence. The guide already discloses static vector contents and the later scaffold hold; those disclaimers do not constitute fidelity acceptance.

### atlas-layered-icon-build

**A preformed four-lobed badge scales up instead of developing the shaded overlapping rosette.** Both implementations preserve the title/plate cut, separate colored and white onsets, completed-icon hold, and late contraction. Their seed already contains discrete lobes, then enlarges into highlighted blocks. The reference develops softer overlapping lobes around a directional pointer. This concerns layer formation and material hierarchy, not a demand to reuse Atlas branding. The guide's tonal-band/material limitation is consistent with the observed gap.

### prompt-device-context

**Dark character steps replace the reference's pale-to-dark phrase reveal.** The native f165 contexts show a phrase extending from dark into pale text in the reference, versus a uniformly dark first phrase in both implementations. The phone cut, blank-screen beat, status wait, and incomplete ending remain. The reference begins faint text at f153 after one blank frame; the implementations remain blank at f153 and show dark text at f154. The guide explicitly authors discrete character steps; that explains the difference without passing it.

### split-result-pane-allocation

**Continuous card narrowing replaces the delayed, content-responsive conversation reflow.** The reference keeps a still-wide translated conversation through f27, then at f28 wraps prose, reduces portraits, truncates its title, and compacts the composer. Both implementations expose a right preview while narrowing a sparse request card. They do allocate space, but their short text and thumbnail strip do not perform the same responsive reflow. Their later result fade is also an authored departure, already disclosed by the guide. A claimed later source pane excursion is not adopted as an independent finding from these inspected excerpts.

### hard-cut-crop

**The much smaller post-cut rise weakens the settle overlapping focus and typing.** Both implementations correctly hard-cut at f16 rather than interpolating a zoom. The reference continues a more apparent diminishing upward displacement while focus and letters begin; both implementations effectively land earlier. All clear the placeholder at f34 and begin letters at f36. The inspected implementation contexts also lack the reference's visible focus caret. Different question wording does not break the tie. These are static displacement/state observations, not perceived playback-easing judgments.

## Executed checks

| Treatment | Frames per export | Fusion nodes | Numeric tracks | CSV rows checked | Active SVGs | Both exports reverified |
| --- | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | ---: | --- |
| apps-output-wall | 300 | 71 | 312 | 93,600 | 24 | Yes |
| atlas-layered-icon-build | 110 | 9 | 45 | 4,950 | 4 | Yes |
| prompt-device-context | 240 | 30 | 135 | 32,400 | 2 | Yes |
| split-result-pane-allocation | 150 | 23 | 99 | 14,850 | 8 | Yes |
| hard-cut-crop | 69 | 57 | 244 | 16,836 | 12 | Yes |

- **Pinned inputs:** All five runtime recipes match their guide hashes and the batch's declared author-project files. The role-key hashes match the ten frozen candidate labels and the actual native exports. The existing ten-export verification record was independently corroborated with the runtime's real `prepareInput` and `verifyOutput` functions under Node v24.13.1. All returned matching current code/input/assets; fidelity remains `not-assessed`.
- **Core then active:** The accepted core archive hash is `307fb6b927e35e6d73779652873d994f5c3e36cb7deba65f22fa64748057a0de`. Bound shared runtime code/config/lock files match its members. The active archive construction adds only each selected recipe and its used SVGs under `project/`; core must be extracted first, active second with overwrite. No dependency tree, source video, or old raster pack belongs in that override. This was a member/hash/closure audit, not an executed fresh installation.
- **Guide/node assertions:** All 190 recipe layers have one corresponding guide node, matching recipe pointer, parent, own interval, and ancestor-intersected interval. All present numeric properties have guide tracks; referenced values/pointers match the actual recipe. This checks the documented structure, not whether Fusion produces equivalent pixels.
- **CSV assertions:** All **162,636 rows** were compared to the Python handoff's generated values, gates, parent IDs, source ordinals, and nominal seconds. Every row was separately compared to the actual runtime TypeScript sampler and gates. Tolerance was at most 1e-8. Text-prefix schedules remain in guide/recipe node controls rather than becoming ready-to-import Fusion text curves.
- **CLI and environment:** README shell blocks pass `bash -n`; actual runtime argument contracts support the documented variants, custom content, and output/verify usage. The guides distinguish Python-only handoff from Node/npm/FFmpeg/Chromium rendering. No install, dependency copy, new encode, or native Resolve execution was performed here.

## Source clock and attribution

| Treatment | Declared film interval, half-open | Native cadence | Retained publication date |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| apps-output-wall | [2100,2400) | 60/1 | 2026-06-02 |
| atlas-layered-icon-build | [2695,2805) | 30/1 | 2025-10-21 |
| prompt-device-context | [450,690) | 60/1 | 2026-03-27 |
| split-result-pane-allocation | [1530,1680) | 30/1 | 2026-06-04 |
| hard-cut-crop | [675,744) | 30/1 | 2025-10-21 |

The five guides name their source films and source URLs. Retained metadata records match the pinned official-channel identity and dates. This is a local-record verification, not a fresh online publication-date or source-master audit. Local frame zero maps to the declared start ordinal; nominal seconds are ordinal/rate, not recovered master presentation timestamps.

**Atlas:** The preserved original has 115 frames and SHA-256 `3f82a00af5acd2228af20a900e41e6ca8b7028219ed7466cca70885614665456`. Its local **[5,115)** maps to film **[2695,2805)**. The public player's 110-frame re-encode has SHA-256 `871dce13569a50ce58912aa62a7f88d6bc7fca203af2f369dee090a7032da9b3`. The batch preparation record and `build_preview.py:87` carry the original hash, selected local interval, film interval, output hash, count, and exact-native-clock declaration. The player's count/clock was verified in the label pass. Pixel identity or a lossless trim is not claimed; original five-frame context remains preserved.

Prompt and Hard Cut guides retain inherited master hashes and 1920×1080 source metadata, while the inspected research copies are 960×540 with separately verified excerpt hashes. The guide limitations disclose that distinction. Do not describe their inherited master hashes as hashes of the source player. The selected source-player hashes and mapping are recorded in the machine-readable report.

All 50 active SVGs satisfy the handoff's self-contained SVG checks and carry original-art rights declarations. The source-reference files are not active editable inputs. Core retains Geist and its OFL notice. Structural checks and nonempty declarations do not independently prove authorship, legal rights, exact font shaping, or permission to reuse source branding.

## Claims and parent handoff

Some guide text says “no encoded candidate” or “no fresh rendered comparison.” Read that as the authoring-pass history, not the current packet state. There are now ten verified actual exports and this bounded static review. Their existence does **not** remove the moving-source, source-fidelity, text/material equivalence, or native Resolve limits. No treatment is promoted to a completed source-quality example.

Verified `review` fields now applied in the parent-owned batch manifest:

```json
{
  "sourceFile": "batch03-source/SOURCE_ONLY_PUBLIC.md",
  "reportFile": "batch03-source/REPORT-R01.md",
  "sourceFrames": 874,
  "extraContextFrames": 5,
  "candidateFrames": 1738,
  "gaps": {
    "apps-output-wall": "Repeated card templates flatten heterogeneous foreground handoffs and page-specific activity.",
    "atlas-layered-icon-build": "A preformed four-lobed badge replaces development of the shaded overlapping rosette.",
    "prompt-device-context": "Dark character steps replace the source's pale-to-dark phrase reveal.",
    "split-result-pane-allocation": "Continuous card narrowing replaces delayed content-responsive conversation reflow.",
    "hard-cut-crop": "A much smaller post-cut rise weakens the settle overlapping focus and typing."
  }
}
```

The required overlay manifests are also now selected for the two editing entries. Next, the parent builds the final public archives, unpacks into fresh roots, applies core before active, verifies delivered guide/recipe/SVG bindings, regenerates and compares delivered CSV, and confirms source player counts/provenance. Preserve both source freezes and the private label freeze. **Batch04 labels were not started.**