{ "argument_aliases": { "$FIXTURES": "tiny test inputs under the authorized review output", "$KIT": "read-only kit code/document root", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS": "new command outputs under the authorized review output", "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW": "supplied existing Python", "$REVIEW": "authorized reviewer output root", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK": "supplied shared lock", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER": "supplied pinned full Chrome ELF", "$WORK": "read-only existing artifact worker" }, "certifications": { "moving_quality": false, "native_resolve": false, "production_approval": false, "research": false, "source_fidelity": false }, "commands": [ { "argv": [ "node", "run.mjs", "--action", "check-prepared", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--pins", "$WORK/build/core-pins.json", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--svg", "$WORK/svg", "--out", "$FIXTURES/prepared-missing" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "check-prepared-missing-files", "private_receipt_sha256": "37fed564301072ec52846892f92d72ee01287b7a09e5a42b1e9e5e1ff8859efe", "seconds": 0.506 }, { "argv": [ "node", "run.mjs", "--action", "check-prepared", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--pins", "$WORK/build/core-pins.json", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--svg", "$WORK/svg", "--out", "$WORK/prepared" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "check-prepared", "private_receipt_sha256": "4b4a781260b2c6a4ddc94d7b135d00bb380a7326d6409fa1e6097823d7932855", "seconds": 0.54 }, { "argv": [ "node", "run.mjs", "--action", "check", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--pins", "$WORK/build/core-pins.json", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "check", "private_receipt_sha256": "4ca253745e80a65a0759352a9e72496d5abe9bdb499336f60f1f334008de35bb", "seconds": 0.451 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/array-design.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/array-design-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-array-design", "private_receipt_sha256": "a1bf608e860e7972482b83af8d58735dc57ea7a74be670cf64a5c54eabad5a70", "seconds": 0.044 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/beacon-otters.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/beacon-otters-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "design-beacon-otters", "private_receipt_sha256": "082268ff2b57c045f30493103eca9f612a76c297fa48ad6613810320a962ad5e", "seconds": 0.063 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/compass-oceans.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/compass-oceans-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "design-compass-oceans", "private_receipt_sha256": "882e35bf11a5d8a278bf81fa9e23ca068ab8556e277a91e935b845be09e363f0", "seconds": 0.06 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/empty-design.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/empty-design-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-empty-design", "private_receipt_sha256": "0a04343e32908e67db2a256517574b95dd5ea381b9afb730ac30cc68d2c78866", "seconds": 0.045 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/extra-schema.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/extra-schema-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-extra-schema", "private_receipt_sha256": "2c198be0c171ad69193f027fbbfce312dc79e459a290939fd137dff185346dc5", "seconds": 0.044 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/missing-family.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/missing-family-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-missing-family", "private_receipt_sha256": "295fceeb9798c92480772c7e61d734d2fc6035b9bbb05d56622817a9a1c5d548", "seconds": 0.044 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/missing-word.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/missing-word-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-missing-word", "private_receipt_sha256": "d4e4a42307de9e3d6dc9a9edf461b5a72caf6a647bc4a6d25e892fc28cff6372", "seconds": 0.044 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/null-design.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/null-design-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-null-design", "private_receipt_sha256": "3623f86a218eb0baa52ee3d74f1ef55c38efa8d1c1ce531179cf42b44c4dc6ef", "seconds": 0.045 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/partial-geometry.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/partial-geometry-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-partial-geometry", "private_receipt_sha256": "77288e094e0516a5edf14a8a074d9aa1ed67beaccb7a7dd7fc0c0c71f5c162b2", "seconds": 0.043 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "design.mjs", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--design", "$FIXTURES/wrong-width-shape.json", "--out", "$FIXTURES/wrong-width-shape-props.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "design-wrong-width-shape", "private_receipt_sha256": "953fdce6a28a1b1cda6445ac22a50f855caf2326267b6376d6723f1779b8e481", "seconds": 0.045 }, { "argv": [ "node", "run.mjs", "--action", "check-prepared", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--pins", "$WORK/build/core-pins.json", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--svg", "$WORK/svg", "--out", "$WORK/prepared" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "final-check-prepared", "private_receipt_sha256": "fc648f88ca6607006fa0c11c2295c12d5b78f293c43154a7074353ce599f58eb", "seconds": 0.545 }, { "argv": [ "node", "run.mjs", "--action", "check", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--pins", "$WORK/build/core-pins.json", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "final-check", "private_receipt_sha256": "b1c14bd5b81899d9e9995a4f8571f0e26c91e421e09fefaa986ef78337460f3d", "seconds": 0.473 }, { "argv": [ "node", "--experimental-strip-types", "--test", "--test-name-pattern", "^(?!(files, not just JSON|prepare CLI)).*", "test_contract.mjs" ], "credit": "34 tests executed; write-scope exception", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "node-tests-readonly", "private_receipt_sha256": "3754b7a42e004d0d062de58e85243630b1675f4d5cd1c20939209584f8b6f345", "seconds": 0.607 }, { "argv": [ "node", "run.mjs", "--action", "prepare", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--pins", "$WORK/build/core-pins.json", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--svg", "$FIXTURES/svg-empty", "--out", "$FIXTURES/prepare-empty-output" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "prepare-empty", "private_receipt_sha256": "42b3062a74e314de1bf5f703d68189ca1fec524357274b3ac1eaf6a3ed8dbda1", "seconds": 0.451 }, { "argv": [ "node", "run.mjs", "--action", "prepare", "--project", "$WORK/build/core", "--pins", "$WORK/build/core-pins.json", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--svg", "$FIXTURES/svg-partial", "--out", "$FIXTURES/prepare-partial-output" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "prepare-partial", "private_receipt_sha256": "825f1e614a0ae1838e2d4235692405f245a1994a06695a83fb4cd1b87d9d803b", "seconds": 0.448 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "test_verify.py", "VerifyTests.test_valid_nonempty_actual_inputs", "VerifyTests.test_summary_rejects_unperformed_measurements", "VerifyTests.test_no_dimension_mismatch", "VerifyTests.test_positive_and_corrupted_pixel_control" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "python-tests-readonly", "private_receipt_sha256": "79ebb2f3fa00b004fca92b6376281f7ae2b16656b30bba7debfc215cf1145ea5", "seconds": 0.068 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-no-research-lockfixed", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "verify-no-research-lockfixed", "private_receipt_sha256": "6ba9a8305cd5ae089dcc39697b577852c9366113dc6f41db7990a7713184639d", "seconds": 14.579 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-no-research", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK" ], "credit": "none; reviewer ffprobe launcher error", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 0, "id": "verify-no-research", "private_receipt_sha256": "365044ccc283c18ee5b07175597d97981891bd384a4914f24d7bb62cc91542ac", "seconds": 0.561 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-requested-empty-file", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK", "--critic", "$FIXTURES/requested-empty-file.json" ], "credit": "invalid-request bypass reproduced; no research credit", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "verify-requested-empty-file", "private_receipt_sha256": "f5fd9760b3985d4f23f7ce572d7390e230ccea1b2a67b544f163f1b501128ba4", "seconds": 14.988 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-requested-empty-list-lockfixed", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK", "--critic", "$FIXTURES/requested-empty-list.json" ], "credit": "invalid-request bypass reproduced; no research credit", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "verify-requested-empty-list-lockfixed", "private_receipt_sha256": "fa83815ae839156530696c6c7a75c3fbbf7abb487c419c66c00593cef97462ae", "seconds": 14.79 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-requested-empty-list", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK", "--critic", "$FIXTURES/requested-empty-list.json" ], "credit": "none; reviewer ffprobe launcher error", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "verify-requested-empty-list", "private_receipt_sha256": "d90866bd7710ef2a38419d1069118941a0836193020585e508ba04d354d02eeb", "seconds": 0.597 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-requested-empty-object-lockfixed", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK", "--critic", "$FIXTURES/requested-empty-object.json" ], "credit": "invalid-request bypass reproduced; no research credit", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 0, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "verify-requested-empty-object-lockfixed", "private_receipt_sha256": "9e728fdabf8980a845923c386fa4b51af5aab5e76d789df0852e01b5937fffee", "seconds": 14.475 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-requested-empty-object", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK", "--critic", "$FIXTURES/requested-empty-object.json" ], "credit": "none; reviewer ffprobe launcher error", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "verify-requested-empty-object", "private_receipt_sha256": "136a5b6360bf28870778aff52729252f269896aaa49ef6f15d382be083906b01", "seconds": 0.574 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-requested-missing-movies-lockfixed", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK", "--critic", "$FIXTURES/requested-missing-movies.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "verify-requested-missing-movies-lockfixed", "private_receipt_sha256": "e466681ef9b3ddab35c139ad97f85cbdc447a098943ada26daca278caf834521", "seconds": 0.601 }, { "argv": [ "$PYTHON_WITH_PILLOW", "-B", "verify.py", "--work", "$WORK", "--code", "$KIT", "--out", "$PROOF_OUTPUTS/proof-requested-missing-movies", "--browser", "$WORDMARK_BROWSER", "--encoder-lock", "$SHARED_ENCODER_LOCK", "--critic", "$FIXTURES/requested-missing-movies.json" ], "credit": "executed", "cwd": "$KIT", "exit_code": 1, "expected_exit": 1, "id": "verify-requested-missing-movies", "private_receipt_sha256": "51035f193d587e3ebf3da3ead3c6fee82d60c1f96b0b688b866e40e37ceab4d1", "seconds": 0.58 } ], "environment": { "arch": "x64", "browserSha256": "9a1fec86405041cdf16c9977d022130c4caf96da6d1a9a20b1767b4ae370e8f6", "browserVersion": "Google Chrome for Testing 152.0.7977.42", "browser_page_launched": false, "chromeMode": "chrome-for-testing", "deviceScaleFactor": 1, "fontHinting": "none", "fontSha256": "73894e0448cae90a92b6c2f8732b7bb9acb7b94c418bff559dad4a18e1de9659", "nativeResolveRun": false, "node": "v24.13.1", "pillow": "12.3.0", "platform": "linux", "python": "3.14.7", "versions": { "@remotion/bundler": "4.0.520", "@remotion/cli": "4.0.520", "@remotion/renderer": "4.0.520", "@types/react": "19.2.18", "@types/react-dom": "19.2.7", "react": "19.2.8", "react-dom": "19.2.8", "remotion": "4.0.520", "typescript": "5.9.3" } }, "findings": [ { "actual": "Empty bytes, empty object and empty array return zero, skip the requested check and emit 604 ordinary rows.", "counterevidence": [ "Nested statuses accurately say not-run; no fabricated source measurements are alleged.", "Omitted research arguments legitimately skip research.", "Truthy partial object exits one with missing movies; that guard is bypassed for falsey data." ], "expected": "An explicitly requested but empty or invalid critic file fails before emitting completed proof.", "id": "G1", "impact": "Success cannot attest that every requested check ran; zero-byte input is indistinguishable from option omission in the emitted verification report.", "independent_refutation": "unavailable; not labeled Confirmed", "locations": [ "verify.py:143", "verify.py:145", "verify.py:195", "verify.py:233", "README.md:104" ], "priority": "P2", "runtime_confidence": "high", "severity_10": 5, "status": "reproduced-single-reviewer", "title": "Explicit --critic request succeeds with falsey invalid input" } ], "frozen_inputs": { "checked": [ "sha256", "bytes", "mtime_ns", "mode" ], "file_count": 855, "inventory_sha256": "5e5686d46ec83a163086341ec1904f9e5e1e7a90c14f7a4480d53b2dad3bf9fc", "unchanged": true }, "kit": "wordmark-outline-finish", "not_run": [ "valid stage comparison", "valid source critic comparison", "source-aesthetic review", "independent official provenance research", "native Resolve", "moving quality", "source fidelity", "edited-copy live font gate", "edited React mount or render", "new render/export/positive preparation", "two isolated refutation agents" ], "reproduction_cases": [ { "critic_binding_in_report": null, "critic_requested": false, "exit_code": 0, "fixture_bytes": null, "fixture_sha256": null, "id": "argument-omitted", "ordinary_rows": 604, "report_status": "mechanical-measurements-complete; fidelity-not-approved", "research_credit": false, "source_check": "not-run", "source_rows": 0, "stage_check": "not-run", "verification_sha256": "30c0ade44d25532e2ed4798c4b7e9be9edce15a8b814bf1c50c066e4baccdcd9" }, { "critic_binding_in_report": "ca3d163bab055381827226140568f3bef7eaac187cebd76878e0b63e9e442356", "critic_requested": true, "exit_code": 0, "fixture_bytes": 3, "fixture_sha256": "ca3d163bab055381827226140568f3bef7eaac187cebd76878e0b63e9e442356", "id": "empty-object", "ordinary_rows": 604, "report_status": "mechanical-measurements-complete; fidelity-not-approved", "research_credit": false, "source_check": "not-run", "source_rows": 0, "stage_check": "not-run", "verification_sha256": "1885b7267253a36f8f88b6f399e658c3957a480639971205e496dce17588fb5c" }, { "critic_binding_in_report": "37517e5f3dc66819f61f5a7bb8ace1921282415f10551d2defa5c3eb0985b570", "critic_requested": true, "exit_code": 0, "fixture_bytes": 3, "fixture_sha256": "37517e5f3dc66819f61f5a7bb8ace1921282415f10551d2defa5c3eb0985b570", "id": "empty-array", "ordinary_rows": 604, "report_status": "mechanical-measurements-complete; fidelity-not-approved", "research_credit": false, "source_check": "not-run", "source_rows": 0, "stage_check": "not-run", "verification_sha256": "e9b0e67efd43488b6d8262abbd6dafe4951902a22ed05c1fa523bd55f1b8d6bb" }, { "critic_binding_in_report": null, "critic_requested": true, "exit_code": 0, "fixture_bytes": 0, "fixture_sha256": "e3b0c44298fc1c149afbf4c8996fb92427ae41e4649b934ca495991b7852b855", "id": "zero-byte-file", "ordinary_rows": 604, "report_status": "mechanical-measurements-complete; fidelity-not-approved", "research_credit": false, "source_check": "not-run", "source_rows": 0, "stage_check": "not-run", "verification_sha256": "30c0ade44d25532e2ed4798c4b7e9be9edce15a8b814bf1c50c066e4baccdcd9" } ], "review_date": "2026-09-13", "schema_version": 1, "scope": "single-reviewer technical commands, edited props, existing artifacts, timing and provenance; no source-aesthetic review", "scope_exceptions": [ "The attempted Node name filter executed two tests that created and removed temporary directories in the input worker; no existing frozen file changed. This is a reviewer write-boundary violation." ], "storage_policy": { "allocated_before_seal_bytes": 2072576, "dependencies_installed_copied_linked": false, "final_global_guard": { "exit_code": 0, "failure_policy": "pause writes and report finalization; never substitute the own-worker ceiling", "headroom_bytes": 161112064, "incoming_bytes": 31457280, "run_allocated_bytes": 28829917184, "run_limit_bytes": 28991029248 }, "guard_exit": 0, "guard_incoming_bytes": 31457280, "peak_limit_bytes": 31457280, "persistent_limit_bytes": 8388608, "persistent_media_created": false, "symlinks_created": false, "temporary_props_removed_after_checks": true, "zip_extracted": false }, "supplemental_audit": { "clock_rows_checked": 302, "edited_designs": { "beacon-otters": { "browser_font_fit": "not-run", "changed_pose_slots": 365, "content_keys": 368, "design": { "apertureScale": 1.08, "family": "beacon", "ink": "#404040", "lobeAspect": 0.94, "word": "Otters" }, "pose_slots": 365, "props_sha256": "e6e97c86bfcf9b15efa2b49275bc7d6f3119b0684bcb838399a56501caec4757", "recipe_unchanged": true, "render": "not-run" }, "compass-oceans": { "browser_font_fit": "not-run", "changed_pose_slots": 365, "content_keys": 368, "design": { "apertureScale": 0.98, "family": "compass", "ink": "#102030", "lobeAspect": 1.02, "word": "Oceans" }, "pose_slots": 365, "props_sha256": "579a602f6c0e71f1e553244fe9e2c810c93a19187c95e2b3e98524519064ed5f", "recipe_unchanged": true, "render": "not-run" } }, "final_dwell": 39, "frames_per_timeline": 151, "fresh_metric_rows_equal_frozen_ordinary_rows": 604, "movies": { "adaptation": { "bytes": 72155, "sha256": "62e44d4e381e9b1f3f793806288163a1dda45ff0994ad3c4ed23889421826e41" }, "original": { "bytes": 82314, "sha256": "d3af7398007407149fe9e25d47b41306089498105958ca40910cfc845abfa5b0" } }, "moving_quality": "not-assessed", "native_resolve": "not-run", "resolve_clips_checked": 226, "resolve_parameter_rows_checked": 302, "sha256sum_entries_checked": 30, "source_comparisons": "not-run; not credited", "svg_states_compared_to_core": 226 }, "truthy_partial_control": { "bytes": 51, "completed_proof": false, "error": "KeyError: movies", "exit_code": 1 }, "unit_tests": { "node_executed": 34, "node_passed": 34, "node_scope_exception": true, "python_executed": 4, "python_passed": 4, "python_temp_directory_case": "not-run" }, "verdict": "changes-required-for-fail-closed-validation", "zip_mapping": { "duplicate_members": 0, "manifest_matches": 276, "matched_members": 276, "member_count": 277, "package_member_set_matches": true, "uncompressed_bytes": 20640498 } }